No puedo imaginar las circunstancias en las que esto sucedería, porque los ciudadanos estadounidenses y canadienses tienen acceso prácticamente completo a los países y economías del otro, pero estas son los posibles escenarios:
Canadá simplemente se daría por vencido y aceptaría su destino. Hay tan poca diferencia cultural que no valdría la pena una gran guerra que de todos modos no se ganaría.
Llegaría el invierno y muchos de los estadounidenses que esperaban beneficiarse de la invasión regresarían al sur. Por supuesto, Vancouver se convertiría en el centro de la comunidad estadounidense en Canadá, porque no hace tanto frío.
La mayoría de los canadienses estarían furiosos y algunos formarían insurgencias. Las fuerzas de ocupación estarían bajo fuego constante. Muchos más encontrarían formas de evadir sus impuestos, negando a Estados Unidos un beneficio de conquistador, y otros se asegurarían de que Estados Unidos no pudiera llevarse los recursos naturales al sur.
Estados Unidos descubriría que Canadá es ligeramente menos rico que Estados Unidos y, al integrar las provincias como estados o territorios, esas áreas se convertirían en costosas cargas para la economía estadounidense a través de programas federales.
El resto del mundo dejaría de comerciar y cooperar con Estados Unidos.
La economía mundial colapsaría y decenas de millones de personas morirían de hambre y enfermedades relacionadas con la privación.
both Canada and the USA would be incredibly hard to invade as both countries’ citizens have access to an incredible amount of individually owned firearms.
What US soldiers should do is to walk to the border, and extend right hand to the Canadians soldiers, and refuse to follow orders from maniac agent orange.
US gets most of their oil from Canada, and at a very low cost at that. Not go mention we can literally shut off power to the US . And with hydroelectricity Canafa is in a much better position.
U have to look up at past routes to invasions into Canada, going north is not simple as you make think it is. Just look at geography of the likely invasion routes are. You would have to go north to the great lakes and then use roads that cut through heavily forested areas. I mean just google it invasion routes would be very limited for an invasion force; this happened a lot with the Germans and allies in WW2 but it’s a lot harder in the American wilderness. There is a reason the US and British invasions failed in 1776 and 1812, limited roads, big hills and mountains and lots of damn trees. They Favour the defender; no tech can overcome this.
Most of your troops have never fought in the winter and it far different up here. Russian could do it as they are used to the terrain and weather. Why would you do this anyway if you have been to the Peace Arch and read what it say underneath. The US wear would oppose you on this. Most Northern states would as well. Go invade Jamaica.
We tried it twice and both times it had remarkably little support; I don’t think its going to happen, especially with Article 5; that would create a really interesting treaty situation.
There’s a chance the US could get kicked out of NATO and then not only would they have to deal with Canada and our allies, but Russia and China would definitely be starting to point some missiles.
NATO wouldn’t support the US as it would be in direct violation of it. Canada will have the backing of the Commonwealth and Commonwealth realm. There would be USA enemies that would also intervene as they know how much natural resource wealth Canada has and would do what they could to prevent the USA from gaining control. Also due to Canada’s proximity to the USA, the USA would have to be more cautious about what bombs or weaponry they use as they wouldn’t want to impact their people. The largest challenge for the USA would be the people, most countries citizens would fiercely defend themselves from an invasion. Side note Canada is by no means landlocked, it’s surrounded by 3 oceans.
Let’s not forget the Russians. That could be an issue. The Russians do not like the US in Alaska, so you think they will allow the US to take over Canada with an enormous northern border facing Russia. Also, with the NW Passage within Canadian waters, more countries would help Canada just to keep the NW Passage out of US control.
The best example of how Canada might defend itself is Afghanistan. A tiny country that has survived numerous invasions. Canadians have to turn it into asymmetrical warfare. And they have to be willing to keep it going even if it takes decades.
NY is so economically depressed they probably wouldn’t mind being invaded by Canada to become part of the Golden Horseshoe if the scenario were the other way around.
Militarily speaking the Canadian army could not hold the bulk of the U.S. army but the American troop would face a nationwide insurgency and popular revolt.
The first line of defense for Canada would be the northern US states. These are dependent economies with deep historical ties among cross-border communities. They would instantly oppose that idea in DC. NATO will come but so will the commonwealth and commonwealth realm. The world hates America more than they hate Canada. Superpower rivals like Russia or China would help in exchange for natural resources and access to the melting Northwest Passage. Think of it like this – If the USA can turn on it’s biggest ally and friend, the world will never trust you. It wouldn’t be as lop-sided you think. War favours those with nukes. Of course the USA has a chance. But it wouldn’t be as easy as you laid out.
Trump has made provocative statements about annexing Canada and using “economic force” to pressure Canada into joining the United States, these comments are generally seen as political posturing rather than serious military threats.
Nicht nur Kanada, sondern ganz Amerika würde unter erheblichen wirtschaftlichen Störungen leiden, darunter Handelsunterbrechungen, Investitionsverluste und Schäden an der Infrastruktur.
Trump is underestimating just how proud Canadians are of resisting any attempt by America to bully Canada (And they have tried many times). The last time a U.S. politician suggested invading Canada, there were widespread discussions about factory workers and power plant engineers planning to sabotage their workplaces rather than allow them to be occupied. America struggled to root out violent minorities in the Middle East. So imagine facing the majority of a country with 40 million people united against them. Other countries would likely arm us covertly. Maybe not the UK or other close American allies, but the U.S. has plenty of enemies with spare weapons and bombs who would jump at the chance to weaken America on its own soil. Canadians would retreat into the dense forests, rugged mountains, and unforgiving wilds of our country. These landscapes are far harder to navigate and control than the open deserts of the Middle East. The vast, heavily forested terrain offers countless hiding spots, making it nearly impossible to locate insurgents. And then there’s the border. Canada and the U.S. share one of the largest land borders in the world, stretching over 8,800 kilometers (5,500 miles). It’s almost impossible to secure effectively, and Canadians could cross it freely to launch attacks on U.S. soil. With no language barrier, intimate knowledge of American culture, and countless points of entry, insurgents could strike anywhere and vanish just as easily. Think about that for a moment. This wouldn’t be a fight on the other side of the world, where Americans can beat their chest, feel proud, and then go about their day. It would happen in your backyard at your workplaces, schools, and supermarkets. Even if your allies didn’t support us, invading Canada would cause every country in the world to distrust and despise America. After all, if you could betray your closest ally, why wouldn’t other nations assume they could be next? Could the U.S. defeat Canada? Probably. But no one would call the outcome a “win.” So, wouldn’t it be a hell of a lot better to just not be idiots and remain friends?
◘
No puedo imaginar las circunstancias en las que esto sucedería, porque los ciudadanos estadounidenses y canadienses tienen acceso prácticamente completo a los países y economías del otro, pero estas son los posibles escenarios:
Canadá simplemente se daría por vencido y aceptaría su destino. Hay tan poca diferencia cultural que no valdría la pena una gran guerra que de todos modos no se ganaría.
Llegaría el invierno y muchos de los estadounidenses que esperaban beneficiarse de la invasión regresarían al sur. Por supuesto, Vancouver se convertiría en el centro de la comunidad estadounidense en Canadá, porque no hace tanto frío.
La mayoría de los canadienses estarían furiosos y algunos formarían insurgencias. Las fuerzas de ocupación estarían bajo fuego constante. Muchos más encontrarían formas de evadir sus impuestos, negando a Estados Unidos un beneficio de conquistador, y otros se asegurarían de que Estados Unidos no pudiera llevarse los recursos naturales al sur.
Estados Unidos descubriría que Canadá es ligeramente menos rico que Estados Unidos y, al integrar las provincias como estados o territorios, esas áreas se convertirían en costosas cargas para la economía estadounidense a través de programas federales.
El resto del mundo dejaría de comerciar y cooperar con Estados Unidos.
La economía mundial colapsaría y decenas de millones de personas morirían de hambre y enfermedades relacionadas con la privación.
PrisioneroEnArgentina.com
Enero 17, 2024
Tags: Canadá, Estados Unidos de AméricaRelated Posts
Donald Trump
♣ Por Isalys Lozada. ¡Así que ahora Trump [...]
1812
♣ Por Candace Herrera. En 1812, Estados Unidos [...]
Fascinación por Pie Grande
◘ Por Sarah Criba. La leyenda del Pie [...]
48 thoughts on “¿Qué pasaría si Estados Unidos invadiera Canadá?”
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- PF The Wall
- posted on January 20, 2025
-
- Bruce Pinchot
- posted on January 20, 2025
-
- The 2 Stooges
- posted on January 19, 2025
-
- Lonely Guy
- posted on January 19, 2025
-
- Permanent Protester
- posted on January 19, 2025
-
- Lawless Lucy
- posted on January 19, 2025
-
- Grizzly
- posted on January 20, 2025
-
-
- John M. Hessemann
- posted on January 19, 2025
-
- Gretchen Burr
- posted on January 19, 2025
-
- Peter Pitt
- posted on January 19, 2025
-
- Sue Pennelle
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Joshua Woober
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Joannie Thompson
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Denis
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Meg Franco
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- City Boy
- posted on January 19, 2025
-
- Riley Walls
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- James King
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Michelle Barrett
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Howie
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Leslie Mackey
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Mackenzie Cartwright
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Xena MacIlroy
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- ClimateUnderground
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- C.J. Morton
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Claudia Malloy
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Kank Caldwell
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Peaches Malone
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Wade Windell
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Simon Morgan
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Leo Rogers
- posted on January 19, 2025
-
- Maddy Marshall
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- 9-10
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Francis Gallo
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Bear
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Fitzcarraldo
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- TeeKay Gross
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Clyde Koworsky
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Billie Sue Hampton
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Earl Isha
- posted on January 18, 2025
-
- Michael DeLucca
- posted on January 18, 2025
CommentPingback: LO MÁS VISTO DE LA SEMANA☺ Enero 25, 2025 – Prisionero en Argentina
Pingback: LO MÁS LEÍDO ☺ Enero 24, 2025 – Prisionero en Argentina
Pingback: LO MÁS VISTO ☺ Enero 23, 2025 – Prisionero en Argentina
Pingback: LO MÁS LEÍDO ☺ Enero 22, 2025 – Prisionero en Argentina
Pingback: LO MÁS VISTO ☺ Enero 21, 2024 – Prisionero en Argentina
Pingback: LO MÁS LEÍDO ☺ Enero 20, 2025 – Prisionero en Argentina
both Canada and the USA would be incredibly hard to invade as both countries’ citizens have access to an incredible amount of individually owned firearms.
No true Canadian es ok with this.
All American Troops would either die of cold or drown in maple syrup
I’m pretty sure the entire world would probably rise up in Canada’s Defense
I imagine the same thing that happened to Germany when they fought the Soviets will happen…THE COLD WILL STRIKE.
What US soldiers should do is to walk to the border, and extend right hand to the Canadians soldiers, and refuse to follow orders from maniac agent orange.
WW3 would start if America invaded Canada let’s be honest here.
Pingback: LO MÁS LEÍDO ☺ Enero 19, 2025 – Prisionero en Argentina
It’ll be a mistake.
Canada is not as rich as the US
It’ll cost a lot of money to support them.
Canada would smoke us…?
This is exactly why Trump made the offer to Denmark to take Greenland off their hands a few years ago. Canada is a great ally. We need them
USA was defeated in the war of 1812 when they attempted to take over Canada.
never would happen, unless its to replace a evil government, like we have ..
Canadians will lose their perfect healthcare system.
US gets most of their oil from Canada, and at a very low cost at that. Not go mention we can literally shut off power to the US . And with hydroelectricity Canafa is in a much better position.
Refineries.
U have to look up at past routes to invasions into Canada, going north is not simple as you make think it is. Just look at geography of the likely invasion routes are. You would have to go north to the great lakes and then use roads that cut through heavily forested areas. I mean just google it invasion routes would be very limited for an invasion force; this happened a lot with the Germans and allies in WW2 but it’s a lot harder in the American wilderness. There is a reason the US and British invasions failed in 1776 and 1812, limited roads, big hills and mountains and lots of damn trees. They Favour the defender; no tech can overcome this.
Trump wouldn’t be that stupid. No Canadian would really like to be American
I could see them trying to woo the Western provinces that already have separatist and conservative leanings though.
Remember Vietnam , went in there and lost thousands of soldiers
People never learn
Most of your troops have never fought in the winter and it far different up here. Russian could do it as they are used to the terrain and weather. Why would you do this anyway if you have been to the Peace Arch and read what it say underneath. The US wear would oppose you on this. Most Northern states would as well. Go invade Jamaica.
We tried it twice and both times it had remarkably little support; I don’t think its going to happen, especially with Article 5; that would create a really interesting treaty situation.
There’s a chance the US could get kicked out of NATO and then not only would they have to deal with Canada and our allies, but Russia and China would definitely be starting to point some missiles.
NATO wouldn’t support the US as it would be in direct violation of it. Canada will have the backing of the Commonwealth and Commonwealth realm. There would be USA enemies that would also intervene as they know how much natural resource wealth Canada has and would do what they could to prevent the USA from gaining control. Also due to Canada’s proximity to the USA, the USA would have to be more cautious about what bombs or weaponry they use as they wouldn’t want to impact their people. The largest challenge for the USA would be the people, most countries citizens would fiercely defend themselves from an invasion. Side note Canada is by no means landlocked, it’s surrounded by 3 oceans.
Let’s not forget the Russians. That could be an issue. The Russians do not like the US in Alaska, so you think they will allow the US to take over Canada with an enormous northern border facing Russia. Also, with the NW Passage within Canadian waters, more countries would help Canada just to keep the NW Passage out of US control.
The best example of how Canada might defend itself is Afghanistan. A tiny country that has survived numerous invasions. Canadians have to turn it into asymmetrical warfare. And they have to be willing to keep it going even if it takes decades.
NY is so economically depressed they probably wouldn’t mind being invaded by Canada to become part of the Golden Horseshoe if the scenario were the other way around.
Militarily speaking the Canadian army could not hold the bulk of the U.S. army but the American troop would face a nationwide insurgency and popular revolt.
There would be guerrilla warfare and Canadian terrain would be a logistical nightmare for America
terrifying scenario
The first line of defense for Canada would be the northern US states. These are dependent economies with deep historical ties among cross-border communities. They would instantly oppose that idea in DC.
NATO will come but so will the commonwealth and commonwealth realm. The world hates America more than they hate Canada. Superpower rivals like Russia or China would help in exchange for natural resources and access to the melting Northwest Passage.
Think of it like this – If the USA can turn on it’s biggest ally and friend, the world will never trust you. It wouldn’t be as lop-sided you think. War favours those with nukes. Of course the USA has a chance. But it wouldn’t be as easy as you laid out.
Trump has made provocative statements about annexing Canada and using “economic force” to pressure Canada into joining the United States, these comments are generally seen as political posturing rather than serious military threats.
We cannot let Trump to invades friendly countries for no apparent reasons, or Trump is acting like Putin.
Or Hitler attacking the Soviet Union
Nicht nur Kanada, sondern ganz Amerika würde unter erheblichen wirtschaftlichen Störungen leiden, darunter Handelsunterbrechungen, Investitionsverluste und Schäden an der Infrastruktur.
Canada, supported by its allies, including NATO, would resist the invasion, resulting in a prolonged and devastating military conflict.
And if Canada invokes Article 5 of the NATO Treaty ?
An armed attack against one member is considered an attack against all members
Trump is underestimating just how proud Canadians are of resisting any attempt by America to bully Canada (And they have tried many times). The last time a U.S. politician suggested invading Canada, there were widespread discussions about factory workers and power plant engineers planning to sabotage their workplaces rather than allow them to be occupied. America struggled to root out violent minorities in the Middle East. So imagine facing the majority of a country with 40 million people united against them. Other countries would likely arm us covertly. Maybe not the UK or other close American allies, but the U.S. has plenty of enemies with spare weapons and bombs who would jump at the chance to weaken America on its own soil. Canadians would retreat into the dense forests, rugged mountains, and unforgiving wilds of our country. These landscapes are far harder to navigate and control than the open deserts of the Middle East. The vast, heavily forested terrain offers countless hiding spots, making it nearly impossible to locate insurgents. And then there’s the border. Canada and the U.S. share one of the largest land borders in the world, stretching over 8,800 kilometers (5,500 miles). It’s almost impossible to secure effectively, and Canadians could cross it freely to launch attacks on U.S. soil. With no language barrier, intimate knowledge of American culture, and countless points of entry, insurgents could strike anywhere and vanish just as easily. Think about that for a moment. This wouldn’t be a fight on the other side of the world, where Americans can beat their chest, feel proud, and then go about their day. It would happen in your backyard at your workplaces, schools, and supermarkets. Even if your allies didn’t support us, invading Canada would cause every country in the world to distrust and despise America. After all, if you could betray your closest ally, why wouldn’t other nations assume they could be next? Could the U.S. defeat Canada? Probably. But no one would call the outcome a “win.” So, wouldn’t it be a hell of a lot better to just not be idiots and remain friends?
If the US wants Canada so badly, why not make a North American Union between the US Canada and Mexico?